E4 — Standards re-baseline
| State | Closed |
| Start Date | 2026-09-22 |
| Closed Date | 2026-09-23 |
The standards and native-framework decisions applied across web, Django, FastAPI and SQLAlchemy. Package docs state the current contract.
| ID | Scope | Commits | State |
|---|---|---|---|
| F4.1 | OpenAPI accuracy, standards deviations fixed, shared web logic and the service surface (health, discovery, deprecation, conditional GET, Retry-After, security headers, body limit, CORS, idempotency runner) |
373d6bc |
Closed |
| F4.2 | W3C Trace Context through OpenTelemetry as the only request correlation; X-Correlation-ID is neither read nor sent (ADR-0001, rule 5) |
630142c |
Closed |
| F4.3 | One wire model per stack, as pydantic models in rn-forge-web |
df7a245 |
Closed |
| F4.4 | Library evaluations, each closed with a recorded exemption | 74b36ff, c1979a4 |
Closed |
| F4.5 | Tabular transfer over tablib and django-import-export, and FastAPI transfer |
cc78e19, a036a50 |
Closed |
| F4.6 | API Improvement Proposal conventions where no RFC applies: sorting, field names, timestamps, long-running operations | 9af1705 |
Closed |
| F4.7 | rn-forge-sqlalchemy and cross-stack tabular work |
653ac47 |
Closed |
| F4.8 | Simplification after F4.2: access log removed, OpenTelemetry log processor moved to commons, traceId rename |
74b36ff |
Closed |
The Django scope review was not delivered here: the split decision is recorded in E15's design and the auth review is E13. The remaining API-convention items are deferred in E12, and the SQLAlchemy items are parked in the ideas list.
ADR-0001 states the order of authority.
ADR-0005 states the shared HTTP contract. F4.2 emits
traceresponse from Trace Context Level 2, a Candidate Recommendation that
OpenTelemetry Python marks experimental; that instability is accepted.
Considered and rejected
- OpenAPI component helpers and
Page<Item>schema naming, withdrawn by F4.1. - Custom correlation-ID handling and its validator, withdrawn by F4.2. Keeping
X-Correlation-IDthroughasgi-correlation-id, or as an alias beside Trace Context, was rejected with it: no standard names the header, and two correlation values can disagree. - Starlette's body-limit middleware, rejected at its probe; the kit's problem response remains.
- The library candidates evaluated in F4.4 and F4.7, each exempt after evaluation.
- AIP-193, 154, 155, 134, 160 and 122, where an RFC or a native mechanism already governs.